Great hidden lunch
Fire Island Rustic Bakeshop2
Why locals love it
This bakery is right in the downtown residential area with fresh baked bread, desserts, sandwiches, and more. You can get a cup of coffee and a roll to sit down there or take with you to the park or for a stroll around the neighborhood.
Why you should visit it
There are pretty much no tourists here, yet it's downtown. The food is fresh and super yummy. There is inside and outside seating, but the neighborhood is pretty and the park close by, you may want to take this with you. Even stop by just to pick up a macaroon.
Don't worry about a line. Get an idea of what you want and there are a few people going down the line helping and it's faster than it looks.